Buy vs. lease · USD estimates

Auto Loan vs. Lease Calculator

Compare a fixed-rate purchase loan with returning one closed-end lease. See monthly payments, cash needs and estimated net cost at the same date.

Your two vehicle quotes

USD · US-style closed-end lease illustration. Defaults are examples, not current offers. Review the tax and fee summaries before comparing.

Purchase loan

Negotiated price after purchase discounts; exclude separately entered tax and fees.
Cash applied to financed charges; not the entire amount due at signing.
Contract annual interest rate, not disclosure APR. Enter 0%–100%.
1–120 whole months. This can differ from the lease term.
Estimated sale value at lease maturity, using expected mileage and condition. Not guaranteed.

Review purchase taxes, fees and operating allowances.

Purchase taxes and other costs
Quoted purchase tax in dollars. No state tax rules are calculated.
Financed tax increases principal; upfront tax increases signing cash.
Purchase fees borrowed in the loan. Enter each charge only once.
Cash fees outside the loan; exclude cash down and separately entered tax.
Monthly purchase expenses. At $0, operating costs are excluded.
Expected selling expenses at lease maturity, separate from resale value.

Price and fees are separate. Enter quoted tax once; no state tax is calculated automatically.

Closed-end lease

Agreed vehicle price before separately entered charges and credits.
Cash down only; not total due at signing. Exclude the deposit and first payment.
Enter the decimal money factor from your lease quote, such as 0.0025; not an APR.
Quoted dollar amount used for lease math; separate from estimated purchase resale.
1–120 whole months. Both options are compared at the end of this term.

Review lease taxes, fees, mileage and return costs.

Lease taxes, fees and mileage
Lease incentive only; exclude trade-in assets and discounts already in the price.
Fees/taxes financed in the lease. Do not also enter them as upfront charges.
Quoted constant monthly lease tax. Exclude tax already capitalized or paid upfront.
Upfront charges only; exclude cash reduction, deposit and first monthly payment.
Assumed fully refunded or credited at return. Adds signing cash, not net expense.
Return fee at maturity; no waiver is assumed.
Annual allowance from your contract, prorated across the lease term.
Expected annual use. Reflect this mileage in purchase resale too.
Quoted excess-mileage charge, $0–$100 per mile. Charged once at return.
Estimated excess-wear charge at return; enter 0 only if none is expected.
Monthly lease expenses. At $0, operating costs are excluded.

Upfront charges exclude cash cap-cost reduction, the refundable deposit and the first lease payment. Those are counted separately. Rebate means an incentive, not a trade-in asset.

Most money inputs: $0–$100 million, up to two decimals. Both vehicle prices must be greater than $0. Excess-mileage charge: $0–$100 per mile. Loan rates: 0%–100%, up to six decimals; money factor: 0–0.1, up to eight decimals. These are tool bounds, not available offers or legal limits.

Method & assumptions.

Estimated cost at lease end

Enter valid assumptions for a current comparison.

Purchase net cost

—

Lease return cost

—

No current estimate.

Resale and unentered operating costs can change which option costs less. Compare similar vehicles and driving assumptions.

Regular loan payment

—

Lease payment incl. tax

—

Regular payments depend on the entered terms.

Cash required at signing and purchase equity at the lease comparison date
Purchase cash at signing—
Lease cash at signing · includes first payment—
Purchase cash paid through comparison—
Loan principal still owed at comparison—
Purchase equity before sale costs—
Purchase equity after entered sale costs—

Break-even purchase resale value

—

Other inputs must remain fixed.

Resale value is an assumption, not a forecast.

A quote-based illustration, not a recommendation, lender quote or credit decision. No early termination, repeat lease or buyout financing is modeled. Comparison periods · Disclaimer.

What is included in the comparison

Entered and calculated costs; all amounts in USD
MeasurePurchaseLease return
Principal / adjusted cap cost——
Loan payments through comparison—Not applicable
Loan interest through comparison—Not applicable
All lease payments · first counted onceNot applicable—
Lease installments after signingNot applicable—
Monthly lease depreciation componentNot applicable—
Monthly lease rent componentNot applicable—
Base lease payment · before quoted taxNot applicable—
Excess-mileage charge at returnNot applicable—
All entered return chargesNot applicable—
Interest over the full loan term—Not applicable
Final payment over the full loan term—Not applicable

The full loan term can extend beyond this comparison. Future loan payments are shown in the CSV, not added to cash already paid at lease end.

Cash flow through lease maturity

Each row covers one equal-month period. The lease payment is made at its start; the loan payment at its end. Cash totals include signing amounts and operating allowances. The final lease row includes return charges and the deposit refund. Purchase cash here is before the hypothetical sale and loan payoff.

Period, loan payment, loan interest, loan balance, lease payment and cumulative cash paid
PeriodLoan paymentLoan interestLoan balanceLease paymentPurchase cash to dateLease cash to date

The CSV includes every comparison period and a separate full loan amortization schedule. Period numbers are not actual contract payment dates.

Method & assumptions

Purchase net cost

Cash paid + remaining principal + sale costs − estimated resale

Lease return cost

Cash reduction + upfront fees/taxes + all payments + operating costs + return charges

Both options are compared at lease maturity. Purchase assumes a sale and principal payoff; lease assumes completion and return. First lease payment is counted once; the deposit is assumed fully refundable.

Taxes are entered quotes. Resale and unentered operating costs can change the result. This undiscounted model excludes opportunity cost, trade-ins, early termination and lease buyouts.

Detailed methodology & sources

This tool compares buying and hypothetically selling a vehicle at lease maturity with completing and returning one closed-end lease. Loan and lease terms can differ. It uses a fixed monthly loan model and a money-factor lease formula; your contracts can use different timing or rounding. Compare written quotes for a similar vehicle and driving allowance.

Vehicle prices, cash reductions and value assumptions

Enter each negotiated vehicle price before separately entered charges. Purchase price should already reflect applicable purchase discounts or rebates. Each price must be above $0; money inputs accept $0–$100 million with two decimals. These bounds are tool limits, not an assessment of availability. Valid grouped commas and a dollar sign are accepted; negative, blank or malformed values are rejected.

Purchase cash down reduces financed purchase charges. Lease cash cap-cost reduction reduces adjusted capitalized cost. Neither field means the entire amount due at signing. Keep upfront taxes/fees, the deposit and the first lease payment in their designated places. Cash down cannot exceed the purchase charges allocated to financing. This tool supports lease adjusted cap cost at or above residual; other prepaid or overfunded structures need their actual quote.

Gross capitalized cost here is the lease vehicle price plus capitalized charges. Subtract the cash cap-cost reduction and lease rebate/incentive to obtain adjusted capitalized cost. Do not enter the same incentive both in a discounted price and in the credit field. Trade-ins are outside this comparison: they involve a contributed asset and potentially an old payoff, rather than just a manufacturer incentive. Compare cash quotes without a trade-in, or account for that asset separately.

Enter the residual dollar amount from the lease quote. Do not assume a residual percentage applies to your negotiated price. Contract residual helps calculate the lease payment; it is separate from your estimate of a purchased vehicle’s future sale value. Returning the leased vehicle retains no car in this model. A contractual buyout option, its fees and taxes require a separate analysis.

Estimated purchase resale value is what you expect the purchased vehicle to sell for at the end of this lease term, with your expected mileage and condition. It is not a guaranteed forecast. Enter anticipated sale costs separately. Equity before sale costs is this value minus the modeled loan principal still owed; net sale equity also subtracts sale costs. Negative equity is allowed and raises estimated purchase cost.

Independent terms and a common comparison date

Loan and lease terms accept 1–120 whole months. The comparison date is the end of the lease term. The loan schedule continues for its own term, with principal remaining at the comparison date when applicable. If the loan finishes earlier, later loan payments are $0. No early lease return, replacement lease, balloon loan or lease-buyout financing is modeled.

Loan interest and lease rent

Enter the fixed annual loan interest rate, using 0%–100% and up to six decimals. A disclosed APR can include certain mandatory credit fees and can differ from the interest rate. This model does not calculate disclosure APR or a regulatory finance charge. Loan interest uses one-twelfth of the annual rate on outstanding principal; actual daily-interest timing and precomputed-interest contracts can differ.

Borrowed principal P = purchase price + financed fees + financed tax − cash down
Monthly rate r = annual loan interest rate ÷ 100 ÷ 12
Unrounded loan payment = P × r ÷ [1 − (1 + r)−N]
At 0%: unrounded payment = P ÷ N

Enter the money factor directly from your quote, from 0 to 0.1 with up to eight decimals; this is a tool bound, not an available or legally permitted rate claim. Zero is supported. Rent is added to depreciation. A money factor is not presented as a contractual APR here.

Gross lease cap cost = agreed vehicle price + capitalized charges
Adjusted cap cost C = gross cap cost − cash reduction − incentive credit
Unrounded monthly depreciation = (C − quoted residual R) ÷ lease months
Unrounded monthly rent = (C + R) × money factor
Monthly lease payment = rounded base payment + quoted monthly tax

The loan installment is rounded to cents; monthly interest uses half-cent-up rounding. The final installment pays the remaining principal plus that month’s interest and may differ from the regular amount. Tiny loans can finish earlier; a cent-rounded payment that cannot reduce principal is rejected. The lease base is rounded once after adding its unrounded components; a display rounding cent is allocated to rent so the displayed breakdown reconciles.

Quoted taxes, fees and ongoing costs

Enter the quoted purchase tax as a dollar amount and choose financed or upfront. Financed tax earns modeled loan interest. Enter constant monthly lease tax in its own field. Any tax capitalized in the lease belongs in capitalized charges; tax paid at signing belongs in upfront charges. Local rules, exemptions and rebate/trade tax treatment are not calculated. Do not count a tax already included in price or another field.

Financed purchase fees and capitalized lease charges increase their respective balances. A lease acquisition fee may be capitalized or paid upfront; put it in one place. Upfront lease charges exclude the first monthly payment, cash reduction and refundable deposit. Purchase upfront fees likewise exclude cash down and tax allocated separately. Enter registration, documentation and other quote charges once.

Optional constant monthly operating allowances let you account for differences in insurance, maintenance, fuel, registration renewals or other recurring expenses. Include comparable costs for both sides. Defaults are $0, so ongoing expenses are excluded until you enter them. Costs are not estimated from vehicle type, and changes over time are not modeled.

A security deposit adds to lease cash required at signing. The model assumes it is fully returned or credited at maturity with no interest, while return charges are accounted for separately. It therefore adds no net cost. If any deposit is actually forfeited, include that cost in the return-charge allowance instead of treating it as fully refundable.

Enter the disposition fee and estimated excess wear charge from the contract or your assumptions. No fee waiver is assumed. Early termination penalties and buyout fees are excluded because the model completes and returns the lease.

Annual allowed and expected mileage accept 0–1,000,000 whole miles; excess-mileage price accepts $0–$100 per mile. Mileage is prorated across lease months, without rounding miles first. Confirm the contract’s total mileage allowance and pricing. Higher purchase mileage should also be reflected in your resale estimate.

Excess-mileage charge = max(0, expected annual miles − allowed annual miles) × lease months ÷ 12 × charge per mile
Lease signing cash = cash reduction + upfront charges + deposit + first monthly payment
Lease return cost = cash reduction + upfront charges + all lease payments + operating allowance × months + return charges

Cash paid, net cost and break-even resale

Cash already paid and economic cost answer different questions. The purchase cash figure includes signing cash, loan installments and entered operating allowances through lease maturity. The net-cost figure then accounts for a hypothetical sale and principal payoff. It does not charge future loan interest after that sale. The lease cost includes the first payment once, the other payments, entered costs and return charges, with the refundable deposit credited back.

Purchase net cost = purchase cash paid through comparison + remaining loan principal + sale costs − estimated resale value
Lease net cost = lease cash paid through return, net of refunded deposit
Break-even purchase resale = purchase cash paid + remaining principal + sale costs − lease net cost

Above the break-even resale value, purchase has lower estimated net cost; below it, lease return has lower estimated cost, with other inputs fixed. A negative break-even means purchase is already lower at a $0 resale value. A lower monthly installment alone does not determine the cheaper option.

A checkable example

For a $30,000 purchase with $3,000 cash down, a 0% 60-month loan and a 36-month lease comparison, the loan payment is $450.00. After 36 payments, purchase cash paid is $19,200.00 and $10,800.00 of principal remains. At a $18,000.00 resale value with no other costs, purchase net cost is $12,000.00.

For the same lease price, a $3,000.00 cap-cost reduction, $18,000.00 quoted residual and a zero money factor, the 36 base payments are $250.00 each. Lease return cost is $12,000.00 with no tax, fees or operating costs. Signing cash is $3,250.00; the remaining 35 payments are $8,750.00. The first payment is counted once. Both net costs are equal, although the regular monthly payments differ.

Limits and sources

This is an undiscounted estimate. It excludes investment opportunity cost, trade-in asset value/payoff, early termination, repeated leases, lease buyouts, balloon loans, prepayment penalties, actual daily payoff interest and unentered expenses. Resale, mileage, wear and operating costs are your assumptions. Changing them can reverse the result; consult the written quotes and contracts before committing.

Created by Kamal Singh, an independent web developer and calculator creator. About the project, methods and limitations. Sources checked October 23, 2026. These references explain concepts; they do not certify this calculator, establish current offers or provide AdSense approval. No professional credential or independent expert review is claimed.

Frequently asked questions

What does this comparison actually compare?

It compares completing and returning one closed-end lease with purchasing and hypothetically selling the car at that lease’s maturity date. It includes the modeled remaining purchase-loan principal, entered costs and your resale estimate. It does not compare repeated leases or a lease buyout.

Can I compare a 60-month loan with a 36-month lease?

Yes. The common date is month 36. The loan’s actual modeled principal after 36 installments is included in purchase net cost. The full 60-month loan schedule is in the CSV, while payments after month 36 are excluded from cash already paid at comparison.

Is lease residual the same as guaranteed resale value?

No. Use the quote’s residual dollar amount for lease payment math and a separate estimated future market value for the purchased car. An actual purchase option depends on the lease agreement and can involve additional charges. Returning the lease retains no vehicle in this model.

Can I enter a zero money factor or a zero residual?

Yes. A zero factor creates no modeled rent charge; a zero residual is used as entered. Neither is silently replaced with a default. This does not mean a lender will offer those terms. Negative values and unsupported lease structures generate an error.

Is a cap-cost reduction the entire amount due at signing?

No. Cash cap-cost reduction is one component. Signing cash can also include upfront charges, a refundable deposit and the first installment. This calculator shows them together, and includes the first installment only once in total lease payments.

Are tax, mileage and maintenance costs automatic?

Tax is entered from your quote, not calculated under state rules. Mileage cost uses entered allowance, expected use and per-mile charge. Operating costs default to $0 and are excluded until entered. Update purchase resale for the expected mileage and condition too.

Why does a lower monthly payment not always win?

Loan and lease payments fund different obligations. Purchase can leave vehicle equity and outstanding debt; returning a lease leaves no vehicle. Compare cash needs and estimated net cost at the same date, including fees and ending values.

How should I interpret a negative break-even or net cost?

A negative break-even means purchase is already cheaper in this model even with $0 resale. Negative purchase net cost means your resale assumption exceeds the modeled cash, principal payoff and sale costs. Check that assumption; it is not a promised profit or future market price.

Does PennyRatio save my vehicle and loan figures?

This calculator processes vehicle and loan inputs in browser memory and does not save them, put them in the URL or send them to analytics. CSV export runs locally. Optional Google Analytics loads after permission. Saved choices are respected where storage is available; closing settings preserves an existing choice. Custom calculator-link events contain tool ID and placement, not financial inputs. Privacy Policy covers wider website practices.